A Current Comparison of Skype vs Vonage

by Andrew Johnson

Published on this site: May 29th, 2006 - See more articles from this month

You have read about VoIP and wish to utilize the service either to get free calls to friends also using the service or for full telephony abilities. Either way, what is the current offers from two big VoIP providers? This article will do a comparison of the three VoIP providers to give the reader a starting point of where they may wish to look for a service.

Skype - With Skype calls to other Skype clients are free regardless of location.

However if you wish to make calls to non Skype clients then this is called "SkypeOut". Calls can be made to the 20 most popular call destinations for the one SkypeOut global rate. At the time of writing this rate was 1.7 Euro Cents per minute equating to about 2 US cents or 1.1 pence. With SkypeOut there is no line rental and no contract fees.

The SkypeOut global rate includes the following countries:

• Argentina (Buenos Aires)
  
• Australia
  
• Austria
  
• Belgium
  
• Canada
  
• Canada (mobiles)
  
• Chile
  
• China (Beijing, Guanzhou, Shanghai,Shenzhen)
  
• China (mobiles)
  
• Denmark
  
• Estonia
  
• France
  
• Germany
  
• Greece
  
• Hong Kong
  
• Hong Kong (mobiles)
  
• Ireland
  
• Italy
  
• Mexico(Mexico City, Monterrey)
  
• Netherlands
  
• New Zealand
  
• Norway
  
• Poland (Poland, Gdansk, Warsaw)
  
• Portugal
  
• Russia (Moscow, St.Petersburg)
  
• Singapore
  
• Singapore (mobiles)
  
• South Korea
  
• Spain
  
• Sweden
  
• Switzerland
  
• Taiwan (Taipei)
  
• United Kingdom
  
• United States (except Alaska and Hawaii) and
  
• United States (mobiles)

It should be noted that unless specifically mentioned, this rate is only applicable to regular landline telephones with mobiles more expensive. However note that Canada, China, Hong Kong, Singapore and United States are listed under the SkypeOut global rate for calling mobiles.

Other destinations are available and it would be advisable to check this rate prior to obtaining credits or calling.

Skype voicemail is available for a fee of 5 Euro for 3 months or 15 Euro for 12 months.

SkypeIn is where you wish to have a conventional phone number so you can be called from conventional phones. The fee for this service is 10 Euro for 3 months and 30 Euro for 12 months. Voicemail is included free if you subscribe to SkypeIn. (source : www.skype.com).

Vonage - Vonage provides local and long distance calling anywhere in the US, Canada and Puerto Rico for the one price with calls to select European countries free with their unlimited plans.

In this article the two lowest fee packages will be examined. Basic 500 - This includes 500 minutes for outgoing calls in the US, Canada and Puerto Rico for $14.99 a month. Unlimited minutes for incoming calls and 3.9 cents for each additional minute over 500 outgoing minutes with rates for other destinations.

Premium Unlimited Plan - This plan allows for unlimited local and long distance calls anywhere in the US, Canada, Puerto Rico and select European countries (some included below).

Included features in both plans are:

• Voicemail Plus
  
• 3-Way Calling
  
• Call Waiting
  
• Call Forwarding
  
• Caller ID with Name
  
• 911 Dialing
• Free phone adapter if you sign up directly from Vonage

Current (per minute) rates have been obtained to compare against the SkypeOut destinations:

• Argentina (Buenos Aires) - 5411 - $0.05
  
• Australia - 61 - $0.05 (other prefixes may be more expensive)
  
• Austria - 43 - $0.07(other prefixes may be more expensive)
• Belgium/Brussels - 32 & 322 - $0.06 (other prefixes may be more expensive)
  
• Chile - 56 -$0.06 (other prefixes may be more expensive)
  
• China (Beijing -8610 - $0.06) (Guanzhou - 8620 - $0.10) (Shanghai - 8621 - $0.10)
  
• Denmark - 45 - $0.06 (other prefixes may be more expensive)
  
• Estonia - 372 - $0.07 (cellular and premium - 3725, 37270 - $0.45)
• France - 33 - $0.04 (free on unlimited plans) (other prefixes may be more expensive)
  
• Germany - 49 - $0.04 (other prefixes may be more expensive)
  
• Greece - 30 -$0.07 (other prefixes may be more expensive)
  
• Hong Kong - 852 - $0.04
  
• Hong Kong (mobiles) - $0.04
  
• Ireland - 353 - $0.06 (free on unlimited plan) (other prefixes may be more expensive)
  
• Italy - 39 - $0.04 (free on unlimited plan) (other prefixes may be more expensive)
  
• Mexico - 52 - $0.12 (other prefixes in Mexico may be cheaper)
  
• Netherlands - 31 - $0.06 (other prefixes may be more expensive)
  
• New Zealand - 64 - $0.06 (other prefixes may be more expensive)
  
• Norway - 47 - $0.06 (other prefixes may be more expensive)
  
• Poland - 48 - $0.06 (other prefixes may be same or more expensive)
• Portugal - 351 - $0.06 (other prefixes may be same or more expensive)
• Russia - 7, 70-72, 74-78, 734 - $0.12
  
• Singapore - 65 - $0.05
  
• Singapore (mobiles & premium) - 23223, 23230, 23233, 23235, 23240, 23250, 23276-77 - $0.05
  
• South Korea - 82 - $0.06 (other prefixes may be cheaper of more expensive)
  
• Spain - 34 - $0.06 (free on unlimited plan)
  
• Sweden - 46 - $0.06
  
• Switzerland - 41 - $0.06
  
• Taiwan (Taipei) - 886, 8862 - $0.06
  
• United Kingdom - 44 - $0.04 (free on unlimited plan) (Source:
  www.vonage.com)

Summary : It is hoped that from the information provided, each individual can relate their own circumstances and call patterns to establish which one of these two VoIP providers would be the best fit if it was down to the two. It must be remembered there is a vast range of VoIP providers.

Whilst all care has been taken, it is advised to confirm all rates and information via each individual VoIP provider.

Andrew Johnson has an Associate Diploma in Electronic Engineering. For further information, books or VoIP items, please visit
All About Voice Over Internet Protocol